I wasn't 100% sure about this look before I started, but I couldn't think of anything else to do, so I went ahead. It turned out looking better than I expected, and I was very happy with it. In person I thought the colors looked very opaque and vibrant, but looking at the photos I wasn't quite as impressed. They looked a little sheer and dusty. I used the 88 Matte palette as directed in the video (except for the yellow, which is Sugarpill's Buttercupcake), but I think it might look better with nicer shadows.
Here's another shot with my eyes open:
I think the lipstick is one of my NYX crayons. Maybe Hera? I like the NYX crayons a lot and am planning to try some of their lipsticks.