The eyeliner is by elf. I bought it in a three pack of eyeliners for $3 at Target because I had heard people say good things about elf. This stuff is crap though - very hard to use. I also got some elf mascara for $1 which is equally useless. Maybe elf makes some more expensive stuff that's better? Anyway I really like event horizon which I bought because I liked the color and because the name is cool. I used Sugarpill's LOVE+ and poison plum on my cheeks.